Badge rules

Market-adjusted points

Badges are facts about past picks, given by published rules. A badge is not a recommendation.

The rule

Market-adjusted points over the season on one market: at least 15 scored picks (10 on totals) and at least +2.0 points in total. Each pick counts as a 1-point play at the no-margin market price at the time of the pick (for picks added after the game, the price at the start of that NFL week): a win adds 1/p − 1, a loss takes away 1, a push counts 0. A straight-up pick with no two-sided price at that moment is left out; a spread or total pick with no price on its own line counts at even odds.

Holders now
8
Window
season

Picks that count. Picks we recorded before kickoff; picks whose time before kickoff was set by the publishing platform (timestamped by the publishing platform) or shown by a web archive copy of the page (archive record); and, for ESPN, CBS Sports and NFL.com, picks read after the game where the outlet's own published record for that expert matches our recount (per the outlet's published record). Any other pick read after the game can only lower a record, and any known loss ends a run. Points use the fair market price at the moment of each pick, with the bookmaker margin taken out; a straight-up pick without a two-sided price at that moment is left out, a spread or total pick without a price on its own line counts at even odds, and a pick read after the game counts as a miss (−1).

Holders

Current holders. Each badge links to the picks behind it.
HolderBadgeSinceShare
Jamey Eisenberg
CBS Sports
ATS · +14.9 market-adjusted points · 79 picks · 2026
Matches the outlet's published record
Oct 13, 2026Card
Adam Henley
Gridiron Experts
ATS · +4.9 market-adjusted points · 15 picks · 2026
Recorded before kickoffTimestamped before kickoff (platform)
Oct 13, 2026Card
Jeremy Reisman
Pride of Detroit
ATS · +4.9 market-adjusted points · 15 picks · 2026
Recorded before kickoffTimestamped before kickoff (platform)
Oct 13, 2026Card
justin Pratt
Gridiron Experts
ATS · +2.9 market-adjusted points · 15 picks · 2026
Recorded before kickoffTimestamped before kickoff (platform)
Oct 13, 2026Card
Warren Ludford
Daily Norseman
ATS · +2.8 market-adjusted points · 15 picks · 2026
Recorded before kickoffTimestamped before kickoff (platform)
Oct 13, 2026Card
Eric Thompson
Daily Norseman
ATS · +2.8 market-adjusted points · 15 picks · 2026
Recorded before kickoffTimestamped before kickoff (platform)
Oct 13, 2026Card
John Whiticar
Pride of Detroit
ATS · +3.1 market-adjusted points · 15 picks · 2026
Recorded before kickoffTimestamped before kickoff (platform)
Oct 13, 2026Card
Jason Reid
ESPN
SU · +4.3 market-adjusted points · 58 picks · 2026
Timestamped before kickoff (web archive copy)Matches the outlet's published record
Oct 13, 2026Card
Eric Thompson
Daily Norseman
O/U · +2.9 market-adjusted points · 15 picks · 2026
Recorded before kickoffTimestamped before kickoff (platform)
Oct 13, 2026Card
Warren Ludford
Daily Norseman
O/U · +2.9 market-adjusted points · 15 picks · 2026
Recorded before kickoffTimestamped before kickoff (platform)
Oct 13, 2026Card

How common

Held now by 8 of the 73 forecasters in the badge count.

Our chance check (Oct 13, 2026): the same picks, with every game's score drawn again at random around the market line, 40 times. If a badge shows up about as often by chance as in the real record, it is a fact about the past, not a sign of skill.

Market-adjusted points: real record vs chanceATS: held by 8 of 26 qualifying forecasters in the real record; by chance about 7.7 on average. O/U: held by 3 of 8 qualifying forecasters in the real record; by chance about 2.5 on average. SU: held by 6 of 23 qualifying forecasters in the real record; by chance about 8.8 on average.ATS026by chance ≈7.7real record 8O/U08by chance ≈2.5real record 3SU023by chance ≈8.8real record 6
Chance check, ATS: 8 of 26 qualifying forecasters held it in the real record; with every score drawn again at random around the market line, 7.7 on average (≈1 in 3 gets it by chance). Rows for 3 variants are in the table.Oct 13, 2026, 40 runs; picks recorded or timestamped before kickoff, archive and checked outlet records. Filled dot — real record, open circle — chance. Holders now are listed above.
Show as table
Every variant and data layer of the chance check.
VariantPicks usedQualifyingHeld, real recordHeld by chance, average
ATSpicks recorded or timestamped before kickoff, archive records and checked outlet records2687.7
O/Upicks recorded or timestamped before kickoff, archive records and checked outlet records832.5
SUpicks recorded or timestamped before kickoff, archive records and checked outlet records2368.8
Market-adjusted points — Hunchmeter badge for NFL forecasters, 2026: held now by 8 forecasters — Hunchmeter
Share this badge Copy link (the address of this badge) · Download card. To quote this badge:Market-adjusted points — a Hunchmeter badge for NFL forecasters: Market-adjusted points over the season on one market: at least 15 scored picks (10 on totals) and at least +2.0 points in total. Held now by 8 forecasters. https://hunchmeter.com/titles/points-at-fair-market-odds/ Each holder's own card is in the Share column of the table above.

All badges · New badges this week