Sportsbook Review · 2026–27 NHL season · 9 graded picks
Matt MacKay: NHL picks and record
Matt MacKay's public 2026–27 NHL picks published at Sportsbook Review. Overall graded record: 6-3-0 (66.7%, 95% likely range 35–88%) across 9 scored picks. Each pick below shows when it was recorded. Updated , results through Nov 10, 2026.
Season record
- Graded picks
- 0
One person counts once. A writer who publishes under the same full name at more than one outlet is one record, listed under the outlet with the larger graded sample, and a pick posted at both outlets is counted once. Outlet columns and channels without a byline are listed on the sources page.
Recording history · 20 recordings, including 8 repeats of the same pick
- 17 Recorded before puck drop (85%)
- 0 Timestamped before puck drop (0%)
- 3 Read after the game (15%)
Read after the game: the pick as the source shows it now, read after the game started, with no verifiable pre-game stamp. These picks are shown and counted in recording history only; they do not enter records, points or leaderboards. What the labels mean →
Repeats and picks read after the game (11)
Recorded before puck drop (0 + 8 repeats)
- Matt MacKay Sportsbook Review Under 0.5 Trevor Zegras · points · actual 0 PHI at CGY · Sun, Nov 8 author odds 2.05 · Result only (no price) Repeat
captured Sun, Nov 8, 11:43 a.m. ET · original page · Player props 5–3 · 62% before this game
Quote
Trevor Zegras, Flyers | Under 0.5 points | +105 via BetMGM | 1 unit to profit 1.05 units
- Matt MacKay Sportsbook Review Under 0.5 Owen Power · points · actual 0 VGK at BUF · Sun, Nov 8 author odds 1.63 · Result only (no price) Repeat
captured Sun, Nov 8, 11:43 a.m. ET · original page · Player props 4–2 · 67% before this game
Quote
Owen Power, Sabres | Under 0.5 points | -160 via BetMGM | 3.2 units to profit 2 units
- Matt MacKay Sportsbook Review Over 0.5 Thomas Harley · points · actual 3 SJS at DAL · Sat, Nov 7 author odds 1.68 · Result only (no price) Repeat
captured Sat, Nov 7, 4:42 a.m. ET · original page · Player props 3–2 · 60% before this game
Quote
Thomas Harley, Stars | Over 0.5 Points | (-148 via FanDuel) | 1.48 units to profit 1 unit
- Matt MacKay Sportsbook Review Over 0.5 Jake Neighbours · points · actual 0 STL at NSH · Sat, Nov 7 author odds 2.15 · Result only (no price) Repeat
captured Sat, Nov 7, 4:42 a.m. ET · original page · Player props 3–1 · 75% before this game
Quote
Jake Neighbours, Blues | Over 0.5 Points | (+115 via bet365 ) | 1 unit to win 1.15 units
- Matt MacKay Sportsbook Review Over 0.5 Carter Verhaeghe · points · actual 0 FLA at WSH · Sat, Nov 7 author odds 1.67 · Result only (no price) Repeat
captured Sat, Nov 7, 4:42 a.m. ET · original page · Player props 3–0 · 100% before this game
Quote
Carter Verhaeghe, Panthers | Over 0.5 Points | (-150 via FanDuel ) | 3 units to win 2 units
- Matt MacKay Sportsbook Review Under 0.5 Pavel Buchnevich · points · actual 0 STL at NJD · Thu, Nov 5 author odds 1.61 · Result only (no price) Repeat
captured Thu, Nov 5, 2:13 p.m. ET · original page · Player props 2–0 · 100% before this game
Quote
Pavel Buchnevich, Blues | Under 0.5 Points | (-165 via BetMGM ) | 3.30 units to profit 2.00 units
- Matt MacKay Sportsbook Review Over 0.5 Brayden Schenn · points · actual 2 CAR at NYI · Thu, Nov 5 author odds 2.06 · Result only (no price) Repeat
captured Thu, Nov 5, 2:13 p.m. ET · original page · Player props 1–0 · 100% before this game
Quote
Brayden Schenn, Islanders | Over 0.5 Points | (+106 via FanDuel ) | 1.00 unit to profit 1.06 units
- Matt MacKay Sportsbook Review Over 0.5 Pavel Zacha · points · actual 2 BOS at PIT · Thu, Nov 5 author odds 1.69 · Result only (no price) Repeat
captured Thu, Nov 5, 2:13 p.m. ET · original page
Quote
Pavel Zacha, Bruins | Over 0.5 Points | (-145 via BetMGM) | 1.45 units to profit 1.00 unit
Read after the game (3)
- Matt MacKay Sportsbook Review Under 0.5 Egor Chinakhov · points PIT at MTL · Sat, Oct 31 author odds 1.67 · Result only (no price) Not graded · read after the game
captured Tue, Nov 3, 5:43 p.m. ET · original page
Quote
Egor Chinakhov, Penguins | Under 0.5 Points | (-150 via BetMGM)
- Matt MacKay Sportsbook Review Under 0.5 Quinton Byfield · points BUF at LAK · Sat, Oct 31 author odds 1.87 · Result only (no price) Not graded · read after the game
captured Tue, Nov 3, 5:43 p.m. ET · original page
Quote
Quinton Byfield, Kings | Under 0.5 Points | (-115 via DraftKings )
- Matt MacKay Sportsbook Review Under 0.5 Tyler Toffoli · points OTT at SJS · Sat, Oct 31 author odds 1.67 · Result only (no price) Not graded · read after the game
captured Tue, Nov 3, 5:43 p.m. ET · original page
Quote
Tyler Toffoli, Sharks | Under 0.5 Points | (-150 via BetMGM )
All NHL picks, newest first
Recorded before puck drop (9)
- Matt MacKay Sportsbook Review Under 0.5 Trevor Zegras · points · actual 0 PHI at CGY · Sun, Nov 8 author odds 2.05 · Result only (no price) Win
captured Sun, Nov 8, 10:12 a.m. ET · original page · Player props 5–3 · 62% before this game
Quote
PHI @ CAL Sun, Nov 8 • 7:00 PM ET Points Trevor Zegras u0.5 Points (+105) Matt MacKay
- Matt MacKay Sportsbook Review Under 0.5 Gabriel Vilardi · points · actual 1 TBL at WPG · Sun, Nov 8 author odds 2.10 · Result only (no price) Loss
captured Sun, Nov 8, 11:43 a.m. ET · original page · Player props 5–2 · 71% before this game
Quote
Gabriel Vilardi, Jets | Under 0.5 points | +110 via DraftKings | 2 units to profit 2.2 units
- Matt MacKay Sportsbook Review Under 0.5 Owen Power · points · actual 0 VGK at BUF · Sun, Nov 8 author odds 1.62 · Result only (no price) Win
captured Sun, Nov 8, 10:12 a.m. ET · original page · Player props 4–2 · 67% before this game
Quote
VEG @ BUF Sun, Nov 8 • 3:30 PM ET Points Owen Power u0.5 Points (-160) Matt MacKay
- Matt MacKay Sportsbook Review Over 0.5 Thomas Harley · points · actual 3 SJS at DAL · Sat, Nov 7 author odds 1.68 · Result only (no price) Win
captured Fri, Nov 6, 11:40 p.m. ET · original page · Player props 3–2 · 60% before this game
Quote
SJ @ DAL Sat, Nov 7 • 8:00 PM ET Points Thomas Harley o0.5 Points (-148)
- Matt MacKay Sportsbook Review Over 0.5 Jake Neighbours · points · actual 0 STL at NSH · Sat, Nov 7 author odds 2.15 · Result only (no price) Loss
captured Fri, Nov 6, 11:13 p.m. ET · original page · Player props 3–1 · 75% before this game
Quote
STL @ NAS Sat, Nov 7 • 1:00 PM ET Points Jake Neighbours o0.5 Points (+115) Matt MacKay
- Matt MacKay Sportsbook Review Over 0.5 Carter Verhaeghe · points · actual 0 FLA at WSH · Sat, Nov 7 author odds 1.67 · Result only (no price) Loss
captured Fri, Nov 6, 11:13 p.m. ET · original page · Player props 3–0 · 100% before this game
Quote
FLA @ WAS Sat, Nov 7 • 12:30 PM ET Points Carter Verhaeghe o0.5 Points (-150) Matt MacKay
- Matt MacKay Sportsbook Review Under 0.5 Pavel Buchnevich · points · actual 0 STL at NJD · Thu, Nov 5 author odds 1.61 · Result only (no price) Win
captured Thu, Nov 5, 12:42 p.m. ET · original page · Player props 2–0 · 100% before this game
Quote
STL @ NJ Thu, Nov 5 • 7:00 PM ET Points Pavel Buchnevich u0.5 Points (-165) Matt MacKay Author
- Matt MacKay Sportsbook Review Over 0.5 Brayden Schenn · points · actual 2 CAR at NYI · Thu, Nov 5 author odds 2.06 · Result only (no price) Win
captured Thu, Nov 5, 1:13 p.m. ET · original page · Player props 1–0 · 100% before this game
Quote
Brayden Schenn o0.5 Points (+106)
- Matt MacKay Sportsbook Review Over 0.5 Pavel Zacha · points · actual 2 BOS at PIT · Thu, Nov 5 author odds 1.69 · Result only (no price) Win
captured Thu, Nov 5, 12:42 p.m. ET · original page
Quote
BOS @ PIT Thu, Nov 5 • 7:00 PM ET Points Pavel Zacha o0.5 Points (-145) Matt MacKay Author
Found an error on this page? Write to editors@hunchmeter.com; every confirmed fix is logged on the corrections page.