CBS Sports · NFL 2026
Tyler Sullivan: the picks behind the Right against the crowd (ATS) badge
14 picks behind this badge, oldest first, losses included. All of Tyler Sullivan's badges · This badge on the profile
Badges are facts about past picks, given by published rules. Badge rules · How badges work
Recording labels: Recorded before kickoff (we saw the pick before the game); Timestamped before kickoff (the platform's timestamp or a web archive copy of the page); Read after the game · matches the outlet's own record (the outlet's published record matches our recount); Read after the game (any other pick; it can only lower a record).
Right against the crowd · ATS · 14 times · e.g. DET at CAR, 16 of 21 others wrong
Read after the game · matches the outlet's own record
Right 14 times against the spread when most other tracked experts on the game were wrong, e.g. DET at CAR: 16 of 21 other experts missed.
- Period
- 2026
- Compared with
- 16 of 21 others were wrong on the example game
- How rare
- If every pick won only as often as the market odds said, about 30 of the 55 experts who qualify for it would earn this in a season. Held now by 77 of all 236 experts in the badge count.
- How it is counted
- A game where at least 6 other tracked experts made a pick on the same market, at least 60% of them were wrong, and this expert was right. Counted over the season. Steps: 2, 3, 5 and 10 times. Badge rules
- Picks that count
- Recorded before kickoff; timestamped before kickoff by the publishing platform or a web archive copy of the page; and, for ESPN, CBS Sports and NFL.com, picks read after the game when the outlet's own record matches our recount. Other picks read after the game can only lower a record.
- First counted
- Oct 12, 2026 (our badge history starts that day)
| Game | Pick | Result | Recording evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| SF at LAR Sept 10 · Week 1 | SF +3.5 | Win SF 27–7 LAR | Timestamped before kickoff (web archive copy) · 1 d 15 h before · copy |
| ARI at LAC Sept 13 · Week 1 | ARI +10.5 | Win ARI 26–14 LAC | Timestamped before kickoff (web archive copy) · 4 d 11 h before · copy |
| DAL at NYG Sept 13 · Week 1 | NYG +2.5 | Win DAL 20–28 NYG | Timestamped before kickoff (web archive copy) · 4 d 15 h before · copy |
| NYG at LAR Sept 21 · Week 2 | LAR -7 | Win NYG 6–28 LAR | Read after the game · matches the outlet's own record |
| ATL at GB Sept 24 · Week 3 | ATL +6.5 | Win ATL 35–14 GB | Read after the game · matches the outlet's own record |
| HOU at IND Sept 27 · Week 3 | IND +2.5 | Win HOU 17–19 IND | Timestamped before kickoff (web archive copy) · 18 h 42 min before · copy |
| IND at WSH Oct 4 · Week 4 | IND -3.5 | Win IND 30–13 WSH | Timestamped before kickoff (web archive copy) · 2 d 14 h before · copy |
| DAL at HOU Oct 4 · Week 4 | DAL +2.5 | Win DAL 34–30 HOU | Timestamped before kickoff (web archive copy) · 2 d 18 h before · copy |
| DET at CAR Oct 4 · Week 4 | CAR +3.5 | Win DET 26–32 CAR | Timestamped before kickoff (web archive copy) · 3 d 1 h before · copy |
| CLE at NYJ Oct 11 · Week 5 | NYJ -2.5 | Win CLE 12–17 NYJ | Timestamped before kickoff (web archive copy) · 4 h 12 min before · copy |
| ARI at LAR Oct 18 · Week 6 | ARI +12.5 | Win ARI 18–16 LAR | Recorded before kickoff · 3 d 4 h before |
| NYJ at KC Nov 8 · Week 9 | KC -9.5 | Win NYJ 12–35 KC | Recorded before kickoff · 3 d 2 h before |
| WSH at NYG Nov 12 · Week 10 | WSH +2.5 | Win WSH 24–21 NYG | Recorded before kickoff · 1 d 2 h before |
| HOU at CLE Nov 15 · Week 10 | CLE +4.5 | Win HOU 24–27 CLE | Recorded before kickoff · 3 d 18 h before |
Outlet pages: CBS Sports, Week 1 · CBS Sports, Week 2 · CBS Sports, Week 3 · CBS Sports, Week 4 · CBS Sports, Week 5 · CBS Sports, Week 6 · CBS Sports, Week 9 · CBS Sports, Week 10.
Outlet record check: CBS Sports Week 2 ATS: published 7-9-0, our recount 7-9-0; CBS Sports Week 3 ATS: published 6-9-1, our recount 6-9-1.
To quote it: Hunchmeter: Right against the crowd · ATS · 14 times · e.g. DET at CAR, 16 of 21 others wrong · hunchmeter.com/experts/tyler-sullivan/#badge-right-against-the-crowd-ats