Pride of Detroit · NFL 2026

John Whiticar: the picks behind each badge, NFL 2026

Each of the 35 current badges on the profile of John Whiticar: what it means and a link to every pick behind it, oldest first, losses included, with the rule and the outlet pages.

Badges are facts about past picks, given by published rules. Badge rules · How badges work

Season badges

No.1 · Prime-time games · ATS · 2026, live record since Week 6 · of 70 · 10–3

Recorded before kickoff

Ranked No.1 of 70 tracked experts (Prime-time games · ATS · levels), 2026, live record since Week 6: 10–3 (76.9%). Field average: 50.2%.

All 13 picks behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

No.1 · O/U picks · 2026, live record since Week 6 · of 11 · 40–29

Recorded before kickoff

Ranked No.1 of 11 tracked experts (O/U · levels), 2026, live record since Week 6: 40–29 (58.0%). Field average: 49.5%.

All 69 picks behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

No.1 · O/U picks · Weeks 7–10, 2026 · of 9 · 31–24

Recorded before kickoff

Ranked No.1 of 9 tracked experts (O/U · levels), Weeks 7–10, 2026: 31–24 (56.4%). Field average: 49.6%.

All 55 picks behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

Joint No.1 on the Pride of Detroit panel · SU · 2026, live record since Week 6 · of 7 · 50–19

Recorded before kickoff

Ranked No.1 of 7 Pride of Detroit panelists we track, straight up, 2026, live record since Week 6: 50–19 (72.5%).

All 69 picks behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

No.1 on the Pride of Detroit panel · ATS · 2026, live record since Week 6 · of 6 · 42–27

Recorded before kickoff

Ranked No.1 of 6 Pride of Detroit panelists we track, against the spread, 2026, live record since Week 6: 42–27 (60.9%).

All 69 picks behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

Top 3 · Underdogs ATS · 2026, live record since Week 6 · of 70 · 16–13

Recorded before kickoff

Ranked No.3 of 70 tracked experts (Underdogs ATS · levels), 2026, live record since Week 6: 16–13 (55.2%). Field average: 43.6%.

All 29 picks behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

Top 3 · Prime-time games · O/U · 2026, live record since Week 6 · of 11 · 8–5

Recorded before kickoff

Ranked No.2 of 11 tracked experts (Prime-time games · O/U · levels), 2026, live record since Week 6: 8–5 (61.5%). Field average: 50.2%.

All 13 picks behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

Top 10 · Division games · ATS · 2026, live record since Week 6 · of 73 · 17–10

Recorded before kickoff

Ranked No.9 of 73 tracked experts (Division games · ATS · levels), 2026, live record since Week 6: 17–10 (63.0%). Field average: 50.4%.

All 27 picks behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

45 picks timestamped before kickoff · publishing platform

Graded picks with a time before kickoff set by the publishing platform or shown by a web archive copy; we saw these picks later. This says nothing about results.

All 45 picks behind this badge, including 1 push, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

Best call: NYG over HOU (Week 7) — the market gave NYG a 20.2% chance

Recorded before kickoff

The correct straight-up pick with the lowest market chance on record: NYG over HOU in Week 7, when the market gave NYG a 20.2% chance.

The pick behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

Verified · 210 picks recorded before kickoff

Graded picks we recorded on the outlet's page before kickoff. This says nothing about results.

All 210 picks behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

7 in a row · SU · market odds 1 in 205 · Weeks 5–6

Timestamped before kickoff

7 straight-up picks right in a row (Oct 11 – Oct 18). Market odds of that run: 1 in 205.

All 8 picks behind this badge, including the loss that ended the run, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

Line moved toward the pick after it was made · 83 of 130 · 2026

Recorded before kickoff

In 83 of 130 picks with a market move before kickoff, the line moved toward the side picked after the pick was made.

All 130 picks behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

Right against the crowd · SU · 8 times · e.g. NYG at HOU, 107 of 108 others wrong

Timestamped before kickoff

Right 8 times straight up when most other tracked experts on the game were wrong, e.g. NYG at HOU: 107 of 108 other experts missed.

All 8 picks behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

8 in a row · SU · Weeks 9–10 · market odds 1 in 53

Recorded before kickoff

8 straight-up picks right in a row (Nov 8 – Nov 15). Market odds of that run: 1 in 53.

All 9 picks behind this badge, including the loss that ended the run, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

Division games · SU 21–10–1 · 2026 · field average 57.7%

Timestamped before kickoff

21–10–1 straight up in division games (67.7%), 2026; the field average in this category is 57.7%.

All 32 picks behind this badge, including 1 tie game, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

Right against the crowd · ATS · 6 times · e.g. SEA at DEN, 52 of 69 others wrong

Recorded before kickoff

Right 6 times against the spread when most other tracked experts on the game were wrong, e.g. SEA at DEN: 52 of 69 other experts missed.

All 6 picks behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

Prime-time games · SU 13–4 · 2026 · field average 59.4%

Timestamped before kickoff

13–4 straight up in prime-time games (76.5%), 2026; the field average in this category is 59.4%.

All 17 picks behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

Upset Specialist · 11 of 22 underdog picks won; the odds implied 9.0

Timestamped before kickoff

11 of 22 straight-up underdog picks right; market prices implied 9.0.

All 22 picks behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

7 in a row · ATS · Weeks 5–6 · market odds 1 in 128

Timestamped before kickoff

7 against-the-spread picks right in a row (Oct 11 – Oct 18). Market odds of that run: 1 in 128.

All 8 picks behind this badge, including the loss that ended the run, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

SU · +12.6 market-adjusted points · 56 picks scored · 56 of 56 had a market price · Weeks 7–10, 2026

Timestamped before kickoff

+12.6 market-adjusted points over 56 straight-up picks in NFL Weeks 7–10, 2026.

All 56 picks behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

Underdogs ATS · 20–17 · 2026 · field average 41.7%

Timestamped before kickoff

20–17 on underdogs against the spread (54.1%), 2026; the field average in this category is 41.7%.

All 37 picks behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

Prime-time games · ATS 12–5 · 2026 · field average 45.3%

Timestamped before kickoff

12–5 against the spread in prime-time games (70.6%), 2026; the field average in this category is 45.3%.

All 17 picks behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

ATS · +5.2 market-adjusted points · 56 picks scored · 56 priced by the market · Weeks 7–10, 2026

Timestamped before kickoff

+5.2 market-adjusted points over 56 against-the-spread picks in NFL Weeks 7–10, 2026.

All 56 picks behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

Eagles games · ATS 5–0 · 2026 · field average 55.6%

Timestamped before kickoff

5–0 against the spread in Philadelphia Eagles games (5 of 5 decided), 2026; the field average in this category is 55.6%.

All 5 picks behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

Prime-time games · O/U 11–6 · 2026 · field average 48.6%

Timestamped before kickoff

11–6 on over/under in prime-time games (64.7%), 2026; the field average in this category is 48.6%.

All 17 picks behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

Bengals games · O/U 5–0 · 2026 · field average 47.5%

Timestamped before kickoff

5–0 on over/under in Cincinnati Bengals games (5 of 5 decided), 2026; the field average in this category is 47.5%.

All 5 picks behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

Falcons games · O/U 6–0 · 2026 · field average 48.3%

Timestamped before kickoff

6–0 on over/under in Atlanta Falcons games (6 of 6 decided), 2026; the field average in this category is 48.3%.

All 6 picks behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

Weekly badges

Week 9 · SU 14–1

Timestamped before kickoff

Biggest upset called · Week 9 · GB over NE · market chance 38.8% · called by 60 of 118

Recorded before kickoff

Picked GB to beat NE straight up in Week 9; the market gave GB a 38.8% chance. 60 of 118 tracked experts made that call.

The pick behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

Joint No.1 of Week 8 · O/U · of 9 · 9–5

Recorded before kickoff

Top over/under record of NFL Week 8 among 9 tracked experts: 9–5.

All 14 picks behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

Biggest upset called · Week 7 · NYG over HOU · market chance 20.2% · called by 2 of 109

Recorded before kickoff

Picked NYG to beat HOU straight up in Week 7; the market gave NYG a 20.2% chance. 2 of 109 tracked experts made that call.

The pick behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

No.1 on the Pride of Detroit panel · Week 6 · SU · of 7 · 10–4

Recorded before kickoff

Ranked No.1 of 7 Pride of Detroit panelists we track, straight up, Week 6, 2026: 10–4 (71.4%).

All 14 picks behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

No.1 of Week 6 · ATS · of 58 · 11–3

Recorded before kickoff

Top against-the-spread record of NFL Week 6 among 58 tracked experts: 11–3.

All 14 picks behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

Biggest upset called · Week 5 · BUF over LAR · market chance 38.8% · called by 34 of 76

Recorded before kickoff

Picked BUF to beat LAR straight up in Week 5; the market gave BUF a 38.8% chance. 34 of 76 tracked experts made that call.

The pick behind this badge, with sources →

← Back to this badge on the profile

Held at the time of earlier picks

Badges John Whiticar held when making picks shown on game pages, as they stood at that moment. Each one links to the picks behind it then. Badges are recounted after every game, so these may differ from the current ones.

Division games · ATS 9–6 · 2026 · field average 42.6%

Timestamped before kickoff

Held before the games on 5 game pages, as it stood before the latest of them (Oct 26, 8:15 p.m. ET). 15 picks behind it then →

Shared best record · Prime-time games · ATS · 5–2 · 6 of 48 tied · 2026, live record since Week 6

Recorded before kickoff

Held before the games on 1 game page, as it stood before the latest of them (Nov 1, 8:20 p.m. ET). 7 picks behind it then →

O/U · +5.8 market-adjusted points · 54 picks scored · all priced by the market · Weeks 7–10, 2026

Timestamped before kickoff

Held before the games on 1 game page, as it stood before the latest of them (Nov 15, 8:20 p.m. ET). 54 picks behind it then →

Top 3 · ATS market-adjusted points · 2026, live record since Week 6 · of 38 · +8.6 over 41 picks

Recorded before kickoff

Held before the games on 1 game page, as it stood before the latest of them (Nov 2, 8:15 p.m. ET). 41 picks behind it then →

No.1 · O/U market-adjusted points · 2026, live record since Week 6 · of 8 · +4.8 over 41 picks

Recorded before kickoff

Held before the games on 1 game page, as it stood before the latest of them (Nov 2, 8:15 p.m. ET). 41 picks behind it then →

SU · +18.4 market-adjusted points · 85 picks scored · all priced by the market · 2026

Timestamped before kickoff

Held before the games on 69 game pages, as it stood before the latest of them (Nov 16, 8:15 p.m. ET). 85 picks behind it then →

O/U · +5.8 market-adjusted points · 74 picks scored · 73 priced by the market · 2026

Timestamped before kickoff

Held before the games on 58 game pages, as it stood before the latest of them (Nov 15, 4:05 p.m. ET). 74 picks behind it then →

ATS · +13.2 market-adjusted points · 74 picks scored · 71 priced by the market · 2026

Timestamped before kickoff

Held before the games on 49 game pages, as it stood before the latest of them (Nov 15, 4:05 p.m. ET). 74 picks behind it then →

Top 5 · ATS picks · 2026, live record since Week 6 · of 49 · 42–27

Recorded before kickoff

Held before the games on 28 game pages, as it stood before the latest of them (Nov 16, 8:15 p.m. ET). 69 picks behind it then →