NHL · Tuesday, Nov 17, 2026 · 7 p.m. ET · Final · Week 8 · Tue, Nov 17

Columbus Blue Jackets at New York Islanders expert picks and results, Nov 17, 2026

New York Islanders beat Columbus Blue Jackets 5–1 in regulation on Nov 17, 2026. 13 of 13 moneyline picks (100%) were right, 2 of 2 60-minute regulation picks. Each pick below shows when it was recorded and is graded against the official score. Updated .

Columbus Blue JacketsColumbus Blue Jackets7-11-0 before this game
1–5
New York IslandersNew York Islanders9-6-4 before this game
Final · Tue, Nov 17, 7 p.m. ET · Market favorite: NYI (52%)

How the picks turned out

13 of 13 counted winner picks took the Islanders; most sources were right.

CBJ: 0 (0%)NYI: 13 (100%) · Won

60-min regulation: 2 of 2 right at the recorded lines.

Over/under: 1 of 3 right at the recorded lines.

Matchup picture

Blue Jackets at Islanders: 18 countable picks by market and lineMoneyline (incl. OT/SO) · 13CBJ 0NYI 13 · avg. price 1.78Over/under · 3Over 0Under 3 · avg. price 2.271 × Under 51 × Under 5.51 × Under 6.555.56.5median 5.5
Based on 16 counted picks on this game; the picture appears once a game has 8. Bars: how the picks split by market; for puck line and totals, the dots below a bar show which lines the sources printed. Prices are the no-margin market price when each pick was recorded, averaged per side. Not shown: 2 picks on other markets (60-min regulation) — see the lists below.

MarketSidePicksLines printedAvg. price at record
Moneyline (incl. OT/SO)CBJ0—
NYI131.78
Over/underOver0—
Under35, 5.5, 6.52.27

Picks

18 picks: 13 moneyline (incl. OT/SO) · 2 60-min regulation · 3 over/under

Within each side, picks are ordered by the writer's record on that market before this game.

Moneyline (incl. OT/SO) (13 counted of 13)

CBJ: 0 (0%)NYI: 13 (100%) · Won

Columbus Blue Jackets (0)

No picks.

New York Islanders (13)

Recorded before puck drop (13)

  • Kim Smith Picks and Parlays Islanders Result only (no price) Win

    captured Tue, Nov 17, 12:42 a.m. ET · original page · Moneyline (incl. OT/SO) 54–27 · 67% before this game

    Quote
    Side Pick: New York Islanders Moneyline
  • Sports Parlay Picks Islanders Result only (no price) Win

    published Tue, Nov 17, 11:27 a.m. ET · original page · Moneyline (incl. OT/SO) 33–17 · 66% before this game

    Quote
    Columbus Blue Jackets vs New York Islanders Islanders ML
  • Urheiluviihde Islanders Priced (1.71) +0.78 pts Win

    captured Tue, Nov 17, 1:11 a.m. ET · original page · Moneyline (incl. OT/SO) 34–20 · 63% before this game

    Quote
    Tapahtuma: NY Islanders–Columbus Blue Jackets Alkamisaika: 18.11.2026 klo 02.00 Suomen aikaa Pitkävetovihje: NY Islanders voittaa Tulosveikkaus: 4–2
  • CBS Sports (expert picks) Islanders Priced (1.72) +0.79 pts CLV -11.0% Win

    captured Tue, Nov 17, 12:13 a.m. ET · original page · Moneyline (incl. OT/SO) 52–38 · 58% before this game

    Quote
    Columbus N.Y. Islanders 7:00pm Preview +119 -142 o5.5 NYI -142
  • Robert Criscola Covers Islanders Result only (no price) Win

    captured Tue, Nov 17, 11:11 a.m. ET · original page · Moneyline (incl. OT/SO) 3–2 · 60% before this game

    Quote
    Blue Jackets vs. Islanders pick: Islanders Novig probability: 57% Play to 58%.
  • Chris Ruffolo Sports Chat Place Islanders Result only (no price) Win

    captured Tue, Nov 17, 12:41 a.m. ET · original page · Moneyline (incl. OT/SO) 4–3 · 57% before this game

    Quote
    Take the New York Islanders on the moneyline, as this matchup sets up as an ideal spot to back a home team...
  • Alex MacMillan Winners and Whiners Islanders Priced (1.70) +0.76 pts CLV -11.2% Win

    captured Tue, Nov 17, 1:42 p.m. ET · original page · Moneyline (incl. OT/SO) 21–18 · 54% before this game

    Quote
    Best Bet: New York Islanders moneyline (-142 at DraftKings).
  • Guy Bruhn Doc's Sports Islanders Priced (1.72) +0.79 pts CLV -4.4% Win

    captured Mon, Nov 16, 7:45 p.m. ET · original page · Moneyline (incl. OT/SO) 10–10 · 50% before this game

    Quote
    Game: Columbus Blue Jackets vs New York Islanders ... Guy's Pick: Take New York (-121)
  • Jon Yaremko Pickswise Islanders Priced (1.72) +0.79 pts Win

    captured Mon, Nov 16, 9:43 p.m. ET · original page · Moneyline (incl. OT/SO) 2–2 · 50% before this game

    Quote
    Columbus Blue Jackets New York Islanders NHL Tue, Nov 17 7:00 PM Moneyline - New York Islanders Read more The Blue Jackets rank 30th in the NHL by scoring 2.39 goals per game and have potted just seven total goals during their current losing skid. Columbus is just 1-5-0 on the road this season, and it's tough to see the CBJ beating an Islanders team riding high with plenty of momentum at home.
  • Evgeniy Sergienko LiveSport.ru Islanders Priced (1.72) +0.79 pts CLV -11.2% Win

    captured Mon, Nov 16, 10:10 p.m. ET · original page · Moneyline (incl. OT/SO) 10–12 · 45% before this game

    Quote
    1.70 «Айлендерс» победят в матче Ставка на матч #2 Поставить → Ставка в размере € 10 с коэффициентом 1.70 на матч Айлендерс — Коламбус принесёт чистый выигрыш €7 , общая выплата — €17 Ставка : «Айлендерс» победят в матче за 1.70.
  • Amedeus Mastrangelo Big Al Islanders Priced (1.70) +0.76 pts CLV -11.2% Win

    captured Tue, Nov 17, 11:43 a.m. ET · original page · Moneyline (incl. OT/SO) 4–5 · 44% before this game

    Quote
    AMEDEUS' NHL FREE PLAY! Columbus Blue Jackets vs New York Islanders New York Islanders -142 (BetOnline)
  • David Racey NHL Picks Today & Free Predictions 2026 Islanders Result only (no price) Win

    captured Tue, Nov 17, 12:14 a.m. ET · original page · Moneyline (incl. OT/SO) 5–8 · 38% before this game

    Quote
    David Racey's Pick: Islanders ML
  • Connor Grootenhuis Pickswise Islanders Priced (1.72) +0.79 pts CLV -12.8% Win

    captured Mon, Nov 16, 9:43 p.m. ET · original page · Moneyline (incl. OT/SO) 1–4 · 20% before this game

    Quote
    Moneyline - New York Islanders ... Blue Jackets vs Islanders prediction: Islanders ML (-150) available at time of publishing. Playable to -165.

60-min regulation (2 counted of 2)

Recorded before puck drop (2)

  • VPrognoze · TIRSlavon Islanders Result only (no price) Win

    captured Tue, Nov 17, 2:47 p.m. ET · original page · 60-min regulation 3–3 · 50% before this game

    Quote
    Коламбус не выигрывал в основное время в Нью-Йорке в девяти последних матчах. ... Айлендерс набрали ход, играют дома и имеют преимущество в вратарской линии. Коламбус без главного тренера и с разобранной атакой не выглядит командой, способной прервать серию именно в Нью-Йорке.
  • Prognozist Islanders Priced (2.17) +1.32 pts CLV -8.4% Win

    captured Tue, Nov 17, 5:45 p.m. ET · original page · 60-min regulation 8–11 · 42% before this game

    Quote
    НЬЮ КОЛ Хоккей 2026-11-18 03:00 Нью-Йорк Айлендерс - Коламбус Блю Джекетс Результат Нью-Йорк Айлендерс (победа) Ставка: 3 (1%) 2.21 «Нью-Йорк Айлендерс» в последних встречах демонстрируют впечатляющ ... в Элмонте, «Айлендерс» праздновали успех восемь раз. Принимая во внимание текущую форму команд и историю их личных противостояний, оптимальным выбором выглядит ставка на победу «Нью-Йорк Айлендерс».

Over/under (3 counted of 3)

Over: 0 (0%)Under: 3 (100%)

Over (0)

No picks.

Under (3)

Recorded before puck drop (3)

  • Kim Smith Picks and Parlays Under 6.5 Priced (1.61) +0.70 pts Win

    captured Tue, Nov 17, 12:42 a.m. ET · original page · Over/under 31–25 · 55% before this game

    Quote
    Total Pick: Under 6.5
  • Evgeniy Sergienko LiveSport.ru Under 5 Priced (2.86) -1.00 pts CLV -21.1% Loss

    captured Mon, Nov 16, 10:10 p.m. ET · original page · Over/under 11–10–5 · 52% before this game

    Quote
    2.35 Тотал меньше 5 Ставка на матч #1 Поставить → Ставка в размере € 10 с коэффициентом 2.35 на матч Айлендерс — Коламбус принесёт прибыль €14 , общая выплата — €24 Ставка : Тотал меньше 5 за 2.35.
  • CBS Sports (expert picks) Under 5.5 Priced (2.00) -1.00 pts Loss

    captured Tue, Nov 17, 12:13 a.m. ET · original page · Over/under 44–44–1 · 50% before this game

    Quote
    Columbus N.Y. Islanders 7:00pm Preview +119 -142 o5.5 ... u 5.5

Recording history · 25 recordings, including 5 repeats of the same pick

Read after the game: the pick as the source shows it now, read after the game started, with no verifiable pre-game stamp. These picks are shown and counted in recording history only; they do not enter records, points or leaderboards. What the labels mean →

Repeats and picks read after the game (7)

Recorded before puck drop (0 + 5 repeats)

  • CBS Sports (expert picks) Islanders Priced (1.70) Repeat

    captured Tue, Nov 17, 11:42 a.m. ET · original page · Moneyline (incl. OT/SO) 52–38 · 58% before this game

    Quote
    NYI -144
  • Chris Ruffolo Sports Chat Place Islanders Priced (1.71) Repeat

    captured Tue, Nov 17, 12:41 a.m. ET · original page · Moneyline (incl. OT/SO) 4–3 · 57% before this game

    Quote
    Chris Ruffolo's Free Pick: NY Islanders -142
  • Pickswise Islanders Priced (1.72) Repeat

    captured Mon, Nov 16, 9:43 p.m. ET · original page · Moneyline (incl. OT/SO) 21–22 · 49% before this game

    Quote
    CBJ vs NYI | Moneyline - New York Islanders | 5⭐ | -165 | EDGE Boost
  • Pickswise Islanders Priced (1.71) Repeat

    captured Tue, Nov 17, 4:12 a.m. ET · original page · Moneyline (incl. OT/SO) 21–22 · 49% before this game

    Quote
    CBJ vs NYI | Moneyline - New York Islanders | 5⭐ | -165
  • NHL Picks Today & Free Predictions 2026 Islanders Result only (no price) Repeat

    captured Tue, Nov 17, 12:14 a.m. ET · original page · Moneyline (incl. OT/SO) 13–15 · 46% before this game

    Quote
    give me New York to win at home here

Read after the game (2)

  • Overbetting.ru Islanders author odds 2.24 · Result only (no price) Not graded · read after the game

    captured Tue, Nov 17, 7:14 p.m. ET · original page · 60-min regulation 6–2 · 75% before this game

    Quote
    Нью-Йорк Айлендерс – Коламбус Блю Джекетс 03:00, 18 ноя 2.24 П1
  • Sportsgambler Islanders author odds 1.70 · Result only (no price) Not graded · read after the game

    captured Tue, Nov 17, 11:43 p.m. ET · original page · Moneyline (incl. OT/SO) 9–5 · 64% before this game

    Quote
    We are having a bet on the New York Islanders to beat the Columbus Blue Jackets. You can back our prediction at odds of -143 on the Moneyline and we think this offers good value.

More markets

Periods, exact scores, 60-minute calls and same-game combos for this game. Graded on the final and period scores and counted on their own, apart from the leaderboards and the pick count above. All sources on these markets →

Exact score (2 picks · 0-2-0 · 0.0%)

  • Urheiluviihde CBJ 2 – 4 NYI Loss

    captured Tue, Nov 17, 1:11 a.m. ET · original page

    Quote
    Tapahtuma: NY Islanders–Columbus Blue Jackets Alkamisaika: 18.11.2026 klo 02.00 Suomen aikaa Pitkävetovihje: NY Islanders voittaa Tulosveikkaus: 4–2
  • Alex MacMillan Winners and Whiners CBJ 2 – 3 NYI Loss

    captured Tue, Nov 17, 1:42 p.m. ET · original page

    Quote
    Prediction: New York Islanders 3, Columbus Blue Jackets 2.

60-minute three-way: draw, double chance, draw no bet (1 pick · 1-0-0 · 100.0%)

  • VPrognoze · TIRSlavon Islanders draw no bet (60 min) Win

    captured Tue, Nov 17, 11:42 a.m. ET · original page

    Quote
    18 ноя 03:00 Нью-Йорк Айлендерс - Коламбус Блю Джекетс Хоккей. NHL ФОРА1 (0) @1.66

Market reference (no-margin closing probabilities)

Before puck drop, the betting market gave the Islanders a 52% chance to win (with bookmaker margin removed) and the Blue Jackets 48%, by the median of the no-margin closing prices behind the recorded picks. Market lines are shown for context so you can compare each source's pick with the market of the day; each pick is graded against the line recorded with that pick. How points are calculated

Lines the sources printed: Over/under 5, 5.5, 6.5.

Sources

14 sources · 15 pages · Scheduled start Tue, Nov 17, 7 p.m. ET; picks seen after puck drop (7:08 p.m.) are labeled. How recording works

The two teams

Columbus Blue Jackets at New York Islanders, NHL, Nov 17, 2026, final: Islanders beat the Blue Jackets 5–1: 13 of 13 experts picked the Islanders. Moneyline picks 13 of 13 right, over/under picks 1 of 3 right — Hunchmeter

Found an error on this page? Write to editors@hunchmeter.com; every confirmed fix is logged on the corrections page.