ESPN · NFL 2026
Kalyn Kahler: the picks behind each badge, NFL 2026
Each of the 13 current badges on the profile of Kalyn Kahler: what it means and a link to every pick behind it, oldest first, losses included, with the rule and the outlet pages.
Badges are facts about past picks, given by published rules. Badge rules · How badges work
- Top 3 on the ESPN panel · SU · 2026, live record since Week 6 · of 11 · 51–19
- Top 10 · Underdog picks SU · 2026, live record since Week 6 · of 74 · 7–6
- 73 picks timestamped before kickoff · web archive copy
- 14 outright upsets called · of 32 underdog picks · 2026
- Best call: CAR over DET (Week 4) — the market gave CAR a 38.2% chance
- Verified · 71 picks recorded before kickoff
- Right against the crowd · SU · 8 times · e.g. DET at CAR, 24 of 25 others wrong
- 96 right of 148 · prices implied 90.6
- Week 9 · SU 14–1
- Biggest upset called · Week 9 · GB over NE · market chance 38.8% · called by 60 of 118
- Biggest upset called · Week 5 · BUF over LAR · market chance 38.8% · called by 34 of 76
- Week 4 · SU 13–3
- Biggest upset called · Week 4 · CAR over DET · market chance 38.2% · called by 2 of 26
Season badges
Top 3 on the ESPN panel · SU · 2026, live record since Week 6 · of 11 · 51–19
Recorded before kickoff
Ranked No.2 of 11 ESPN panelists we track, straight up, 2026, live record since Week 6: 51–19 (72.9%).
Top 10 · Underdog picks SU · 2026, live record since Week 6 · of 74 · 7–6
Recorded before kickoff
Ranked No.7 of 74 tracked experts (Underdogs SU · levels), 2026, live record since Week 6: 7–6 (53.8%). Field average: 37.4%.
73 picks timestamped before kickoff · web archive copy
Graded picks with a time before kickoff set by the publishing platform or shown by a web archive copy; we saw these picks later. This says nothing about results.
All 73 picks behind this badge, including 1 tie game, with sources →
14 outright upsets called · of 32 underdog picks · 2026
Timestamped before kickoff (web archive copy)
Picked 14 underdogs to win outright that did, out of 32 straight-up underdog picks.
All 33 picks behind this badge, including 1 tie game, with sources →
Best call: CAR over DET (Week 4) — the market gave CAR a 38.2% chance
Timestamped before kickoff (web archive copy)
The correct straight-up pick with the lowest market chance on record: CAR over DET in Week 4, when the market gave CAR a 38.2% chance.
Verified · 71 picks recorded before kickoff
Graded picks we recorded on the outlet's page before kickoff. This says nothing about results.
Right against the crowd · SU · 8 times · e.g. DET at CAR, 24 of 25 others wrong
Timestamped before kickoff (web archive copy)
Right 8 times straight up when most other tracked experts on the game were wrong, e.g. DET at CAR: 24 of 25 other experts missed.
96 right of 148 · prices implied 90.6
Read after the game · matches the outlet's own record
96 of 148 straight-up picks right; market prices implied 90.6.
All 149 picks behind this badge, including 1 tie game, with sources →
Weekly badges
Week 9 · SU 14–1
Recorded before kickoff
14–1 straight up in NFL Week 9, 2026.
Biggest upset called · Week 9 · GB over NE · market chance 38.8% · called by 60 of 118
Recorded before kickoff
Picked GB to beat NE straight up in Week 9; the market gave GB a 38.8% chance. 60 of 118 tracked experts made that call.
Biggest upset called · Week 5 · BUF over LAR · market chance 38.8% · called by 34 of 76
Recorded before kickoff
Picked BUF to beat LAR straight up in Week 5; the market gave BUF a 38.8% chance. 34 of 76 tracked experts made that call.
Week 4 · SU 13–3
Read after the game · matches the outlet's own record
13–3 straight up in NFL Week 4, 2026.
Biggest upset called · Week 4 · CAR over DET · market chance 38.2% · called by 2 of 26
Timestamped before kickoff (web archive copy)
Picked CAR to beat DET straight up in Week 4; the market gave CAR a 38.2% chance. 2 of 26 tracked experts made that call.
Held at the time of earlier picks
Badges Kalyn Kahler held when making picks shown on game pages, as they stood at that moment. Each one links to the picks behind it then. Badges are recounted after every game, so these may differ from the current ones.
SU · +8.5 market-adjusted points · 59 picks scored · all priced by the market · Weeks 4–7, 2026
Read after the game · matches the outlet's own record
Held before the games on 55 game pages, as it stood before the latest of them (Oct 29, 8:15 p.m. ET). 59 picks behind it then →
SU · +11.3 market-adjusted points · 143 picks scored · all priced by the market · 2026
Read after the game · matches the outlet's own record
Held before the games on 21 game pages, as it stood before the latest of them (Nov 16, 8:15 p.m. ET). 143 picks behind it then →